华东师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版) ›› 2019, Vol. 51 ›› Issue (6): 14-22.doi: 10.16382/j.cnki.1000-5579.2019.06.002

• 国家与社会治理 • 上一篇    下一篇

作为社会价值形态的道德与法律

高国希   

  1. 复旦大学马克思主义学院 上海, 200433
  • 发布日期:2019-11-25
  • 通讯作者: 国家社科基金重大项目"国家治理现代化过程中的依法治国与以德治国关系研究"(项目编号:14ZDC005)。
  • 作者简介:高国希,复旦大学马克思主义学院教授,博士生导师(上海,200433)。

Morality and Law as Forms of Social Values

GAO Guo-xi   

  • Published:2019-11-25

摘要: 为什么道德和法律可以相提并论?它们能够结合在一起的理由是什么?道德和法律都是社会的特殊价值形态,表征着这个社会占主导地位的意志需要和意义追求。社会的主流价值通过制度和信仰系统维系,现代国家和法律的合法性、合伦理性依据,正是基于正义。道德与法律建基于同样的价值根基和意识结构。康德把"道德"(与"自然"相对的"自由")学说分为"法权论"与"德性论",儒家传统把礼、法(刑)、德、政相结合,说明了结合的依据与悠久历史。法律有其价值基础,满足道德或者正义的一定条件,才能称为良法,衡平法就被认为是源于绝对的自然法则、高于人类法的"自然正义"而用来对人为法的纠正。立法家需要理解立法的艺术、立法的原则和精神。法律法规应当是国家的价值目标、社会的价值取向、公民的价值准则的体现。法律服务于社会目的与利益,法的规条具有内在的意蕴、精神、良知。德需要法的保障,法律也着眼于美德和人性的提升,政府有责任培养公民道德、公共德性。在不同的社会文化中,法治德治的内涵和实现方式有其自身的特点。

关键词: 社会价值形态, 道德, 法律, 德治, 法治

Abstract: Why can morality and law be mentioned in the same breath? Why can they be combined? Because both of them are special forms of social values, symbolizing the dominating will and pursue of meaning in a society. The mainstream values in the society are maintained through institutions and the belief system, and the legitimacy and ethicality of modern nations as well as their laws are based on justice. Morality and law are established on the same value foundation and consciousness structure. Kant divided moral theories("freedom" opposite to "nature") into rechtslehre and virtue theories, whereas the Confucian tradition combines li(rites), fa(law or legal punishment), morals and politics, which provides the foundation for the combination of morality and law and shows a long history of this practice. Law has its value foundation, that is, only law that meets certain requirements of morality or justice can be dubbed conscience law. It is perceived that law of equity originates from absolute natural law, "natural justice" that is beyond and able to correct human law. Law makers should master the art of law making as well as its principles and spirit to make sure that laws and regulations embody national value aims, social value orientation and citizens' value criterions. Law is at service of social aims and benefits, and the items of law should imply inherent connotations, spirit and conscience. Morality needs the protection of law, while law should aim to elevate virtues and humanity and hence the government is accountable to cultivating the morals of citizens and virtues of the public. In different social cultures, the connotations of ruling by law and ruling by morality as well as their realization methods have different features.

Key words: forms of social values, morality, law, rule by morality, rule by law