华东师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版) ›› 2021, Vol. 53 ›› Issue (4): 83-96.doi: 10.16382/j.cnki.1000-5579.2021.04.008

• 文学研究 • 上一篇    下一篇

“今文苑”与“小说言”:论李开先的群像叙事

叶晔   

  • 出版日期:2021-07-15 发布日期:2021-07-19
  • 作者简介:叶晔,浙江大学中文系教授(杭州,310058)

“Today’s Literati” and “Fictional Discourse”:On LI Kai-xian’s Narrative of Group-Figures

Ye YE   

  • Online:2021-07-15 Published:2021-07-19

摘要:

李开先《李中麓闲居集》卷九至十中有二十余篇文传,涉及对“弘治七子”与“嘉靖八才子”的评价,且与其《九子诗》《六十子诗》构成隐性的文本对话,呈现出一组颇具特色的作家群像,体现了较明确的当代文学史书写意识。但在嘉靖后期,一位作家要在没有接受委托的情况下,主动为同时代作家立传,其掌握的原始素材,在很大程度上受限于书册的传播速度,李开先亦自诉其苦。故讨论其传记中的叙事技法,不应视作“独立文本”予以开放式的阐释,而应建立在与其“前文本”对勘细读的基础之上,探问作者对志状、文集、见闻等不同文献层级的差别态度。尤可注意的是,李开先作为一位杰出的戏曲家与藏书家,对通俗文类抱有很大的热情,故积极地将俗文学元素植入传统的传记写作之中。白话小说语言及其技法的介入,口传文学书籍化大势下对口述史材料的再重视,基于知识人市侩化习气的审丑模式开拓,皆可视为李开先对时代文学新风的捕捉及在文传创作中的有益尝试。

关键词: 李开先, 传记文学, 史料层级, 今文苑传, 叙事技法

Abstract:

There are more than twenty biographies in Chapters Nine and Ten of the Collected Works of Idle Living by LI Kai-xian. These biographies include his evaluation of the “Seven Masters of Hongzhi” and “Eight Talents of Jiajing”, secretively forming a textual dialogue with his “Poems on the Nine Masters” and “Poems on the Sixty Masters”. They characterize a special group of literati figures and reflect his awareness of writing a contemporary literary history. However, during the late Jiajing reign, as LI Kai-xian complained, it was difficult for an un-commissioned writer to write a biography for his contemporaries, since the mastery of original materials was always limited to the circulation of books. Therefore, once we discuss the narrative technique of these biographies, it is essential to avoid an open interpretation over the “textual independence, ” but to investigate the writer’s attitude towards different layered historical materials, such as official biographies, literary collections, or hearsays and rumors. The precondition for such an investigation is a careful textual collation on the biographies and their “pretexts.” As a famous dramatist and book collector, LI Kai-xian is passionate about popular literature, thus he actively employs various elements of popular literature into the writing of biographies. Vernacular or fictional languages are applied, oral historical materials are rediscovered under the trend of publishing oral literature, and the new tendency of “appreciation of ugliness” is established based on the commercialization over the literati- these are LI Kai-xian’s useful attempt at writing biographies while encountering a new time of literature.

Key words: LI Kai-xian, biography, layered historical materials, biographies of “today’s Literati”, narrative technique