华东师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版) ›› 2024, Vol. 56 ›› Issue (6): 25-39.doi: 10.16382/j.cnki.1000-5579.2024.06.003

• 历史研究 • 上一篇    下一篇

“蜃炭”详解——兼及《左传》 “书法”与商周文化之异

彭华   

  • 出版日期:2024-11-15 发布日期:2024-12-02
  • 作者简介:彭华,四川大学古籍整理研究所教授(成都,610064)
  • 基金资助:
    国家社科基金重大项目“中国国家起源研究的理论与方法”(项目编号:12&ZD133)。

Detailed Explanation of “Shentan”:Also on the “Rhetoric” of The Chronicle of Zuo and the Differences between Shang and Zhou Cultures

Hua Peng   

  • Online:2024-11-15 Published:2024-12-02

摘要:

历代人士对《左传·成公二年》 所说“蜃炭”有不同的理解。结合传世文献、考古资料和生活阅历考察,“蜃炭”当指蜃灰与木炭。蜃炭用于墓葬时具有杀菌、防潮和防盗的功能。考古资料显示,墓葬之用蜃炭,产生于西周中期,流行于东周以降,而商人与殷遗墓葬则不见使用蜃炭的葬俗,反映了商周文化之间的差异。《左传》 关于宋文公丧礼的记载,实则具有“微言大义”,隐含着对宋文公的贬斥,除从历史角度揭示其事实外(“秉笔直书”),尚可从经学角度分析其“大义”(“蕴含褒贬”)。

关键词: 《左传》, 蜃炭, 三重证据, 经史视角, 商周文化

Abstract:

There are different understandings of the term “shentan” mentioned in the “Second Year of Duke Cheng” in The Chronicle of Zuo. By combining historical documents handed down for generations, archaeological materials, and life experiences, we find that “shentan” refers to mussel grey and charcoal. The material was mainly used for sterilization and also had the effect of moisture-proof and theft-proof in burials. Archaeological data show that the use of “shentan” in tombs originated in the mid-Western Zhou Dynasty and became popular in the Eastern Zhou Dynasty. However, the burial custom of using “shentan” cannot be found in Shang tombs that still remain. This shows that Shang and Zhou cultures were different. The record of the funeral of Duke Wen of Song in The Chronicle of Zuo rhetorically implies a derogatory view of Duke Wen of Song. In addition to revealing its facts from a perspective of history, its “deep meaning” can also be analyzed from a perspective of classical learning.

Key words: The Chronicle of Zuo, shentan, triple evidences, perspectives of classical learning and history, Shang and Zhou cultures