华东师范大学(哲学社会科学版) ›› 2019, Vol. 51 ›› Issue (4): 29-41.doi: 10.16382/j.cnki.1000-5579.2019.04.003

• 特稿 • 上一篇    下一篇

危机时刻的文学批评——以钱锺书、奥尔巴赫、巴赫金为对照的阐释

王德威   

  1. 哈佛大学东亚系暨比较文学系
  • 出版日期:2019-07-15 发布日期:2019-07-22
  • 作者简介:王德威,哈佛大学东亚系暨比较文学系亨德森(Edward C. Henderson)讲座教授(美国,波士顿)。

Literary Criticism in the Time of Crisis: A Comparative Study of QIAN Zhong-shu,Auerbach and Bakhtin

Der-wei WANG   

  • Online:2019-07-15 Published:2019-07-22

摘要: 钱锺书抗战时期撰写的《谈艺录》,与奥尔巴赫的《摹仿论:西方文学中现实的再现》和巴赫金的《拉伯雷和他的世界》都是在民族的危机时刻写就的,三者可以被视为世界比较文学事件作对照性阅读。这三本书无论就体例、风格、方法学以及世界观而言都极为不同。但它们既成于战时,作者面对文明崩解以及个体生命的困顿,都有不能已于言者的反思,而他们所展现的宏大历史视野、浑厚的学术知识、锐利的批评洞见,俨然为"发愤著书"平添现代意涵。有关这三位学者及其论述的阐释所在多有,但最值得注意的,与其说是个别著作的深入解析,不如说是面对"危机时刻",钱锺书、奥尔巴赫、巴赫金为何及如何从文学入手,寻求因应之道,他们在批评文字里所投注的情感以及赖以发挥的意象。由此可以考察除了历史因缘外,三部经典为我们带来的方法学启示和与此时此地的文化政治的关联。

关键词: 钱锺书, 《谈艺录》, 《摹仿论》, 《拉伯雷和他的世界》, 忧患著书, 旁通连类, 喻象, 众声喧哗

Abstract: QIAN Zhong-shu's Notes on Literature and Arts(Tanyilu),Erich Auerbach's Mimesis:The Representation of Reality in Western Literature and M.Bakhtin's Rebelais and His World were created in the time of national crisis,so that they can be comparatively read as literary events in the world. These three books are very different as far as their genres,styles,methodologies and world views are concerned. However,since they were all completed at the wartime,the authors had similar uncontrollable reflection on the decline of civilization and the distress of individual life. Moreover,their grand view of history,broad academic knowledge and deep insight into literary criticism has brought modern significance to "writing in sufferings". Although these three scholars and their works can be interpreted from various perspectives,the overriding concern is not a detailed analysis of some of their works but why and how QIAN,Auerbach and Bakhtin found solutions in literature,which emotions they have put into literary criticism and which images they have relied on to develop their doctrines. Besides their historical backgrounds,we can also examine how these three masterpieces will bring us inspirations in terms of methodology and their political and cultural correlations.

Key words: time of crisis, writing in sufferings, analogy, metaphor, heteroglossia, “contemporaries as different generations, coexisting while diverging”