华东师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版) ›› 2025, Vol. 57 ›› Issue (4): 122-133.doi: 10.16382/j.cnki.1000-5579.2025.04.010

• 法律研究 • 上一篇    

论我国监察官的有限独立行使监察权

陈海锋   

  • 接受日期:2025-06-27 出版日期:2025-07-15 发布日期:2025-07-31
  • 作者简介:陈海锋,上海社会科学院法学研究所副研究员(上海,200020)
  • 基金资助:
    上海市社科规划一般项目“监检关系视角下的《监察法》 实施问题研究”(项目编号:2019BFX005)。

On China’s Supervisors’ Supervisory Power with Limited Independence

Haifeng Chen   

  • Accepted:2025-06-27 Online:2025-07-15 Published:2025-07-31

摘要:

我国的监察机关依法独立行使监察权原则以监察机关的整体独立为核心,对监察官行权的独立性重视不足,在强力反腐败的同时可能降低权力行使的效率、无法发挥内部组织积极性,还会造成一定的追责难问题。监察官独立行权应是监察独立原则和监察官法的当然内容,也是防止监察一体弊端和保障监察权正确行使的需要;有限的监察官独立行权与监察体制改革并不冲突,而职务犯罪办理的共通性为其向司法权提供了借鉴便利。监察官有限独立行权的构建应以强化其任职资格为前提,根据监察事项的重要性与具体监察职权的影响分别授权监察官和其他办案组织为核心,结合检察提前介入调查机制与被调查人权利的增设来制约监察官,全面实现监察独立原则。

关键词: 监察权, 监察独立, 监察一体, 监察官独立

Abstract:

The principle of supervisory organs’ exercising their supervisory power independently in accordance with the law in China is centered on the overall independence of supervisory organs, without sufficient attention to the independence of supervisors. While vigorously combating corruption, this may reduce the efficiency of power exercise, fail to mobilize the enthusiasm of internal organizations, and cause certain problems of accountability. The independent exercise of power by supervisors should be an inherent part of the principle of independent supervision and Oversight Officials Law. This is also essential to preventing the drawbacks of the integrated supervision and ensuring the correct exercise of supervisory powers. The supervisors’ exercising of power with limited independence is not in conflict with the reform of the national supervision system, and can draw lessons from the judicial power due to the commonality of handling duty-related crimes. To realize the principle of supervisory independence, the construction of supervisors’ limited independent exercise of power should be premised on strengthening their qualifications and centered on authorizing supervisors and other case-handling organizations according to the importance of the supervisory matters and the impact of specific supervisory powers, combining with the early intervention of the procuratorate in the investigation and the addition of the rights of the investigated persons.

Key words: supervisory power, independent supervision, integrated supervision, independence of supervisors