华东师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版) ›› 2026, Vol. 58 ›› Issue (2): 1-12.doi: 10.16382/j.cnki.1000-5579.2026.02.001

• 历史研究 •    

天子之笑:宋哲宗的表情政治

程民生   

  • 接受日期:2026-02-11 出版日期:2026-03-15 发布日期:2026-03-31
  • 作者简介:程民生,河南大学历史文化学院教授(开封,475001)

The Emperor’s Smiles:The Expression Politics of Emperor Zhezong in the Song Dynasty

Minsheng Cheng   

  • Accepted:2026-02-11 Online:2026-03-15 Published:2026-03-31

摘要:

宋哲宗多笑,在位15年史籍记载42次笑,实际上所有的笑都在绍圣、元符年间亲政的6年中,平均每年记录7次,在宋代诸帝中频次最高。宋哲宗生性不苟言笑,但对身边的执政大臣却改为多笑,显然是统治需要。宋哲宗之笑大致分为赞同之笑、婉拒之笑、安抚之笑、复合之笑、自信自豪之笑、模棱两可之笑、喜悦娱乐之笑、讥讽之笑等。其中以赞同之笑为多,次之为婉拒之笑,说明少年天子的成长过程,对大臣辅佐的依赖性较强。宋哲宗与大臣笑脸相处,以笑代言,用笑脸赞同或否决大臣意见,实为宋代皇帝“与士大夫治天下”理念的表情体现和证例,彰显了君权柔性运作的智慧,一定程度上可视为宋代帝王的软实力,为审视中国古代政治文明的多元性提供了有意思的参考样本。

关键词: 宋哲宗, 笑, “与士大夫治天下”, 情感政治

Abstract:

Emperor Zhezong in the Song Dynasty smiled a lot, with 41 cases of smiles in the historical records during his 15-year-reign. Moreover, all the cases were recorded in his six years of independent rule during Shaosheng and Yuanfu periods, with an average of 6.8 cases per year, which was the highest among the emperors in the Song Dynasty. Zhezong was unsmiling by nature, but he smiled more at the ministers around him, which was obviously required by “ruling the world with scholar-officials”. The emperor’s smiles can be roughly divided into approval smiles, refusal smiles, appeasement smiles, compound smiles, confident and proud smiles, ambiguous smiles, joyful smiles and sarcastic smiles. Among them, the smiles of approval are the most, followed by the smiles of refusal, which shows that the growth process of the young emperor is highly dependent on the assistance of ministers. Emperor Zhezong got along with his ministers with smiles, endorsed or rejected the ministers’ opinions with smiles, which was actually the expression embodiment and proof of the Emperor’s belief of “ruling the world with scholar-officials” in the Song Dynasty. This shows the wisdom of the flexible operation of monarchical power, and to some extent, it could be regarded as the soft power of the Emperor of the Song Dynasty, providing an interesting reference sample for examining the diversity of ancient political culture in China.

Key words: Emperor Zhezong in the Song Dynasty, smiles, “ruling the world with scholar-officials”, emotional politics