华东师范大学(哲学社会科学版) ›› 2017, Vol. 49 ›› Issue (3): 1-15.doi: 10.16382/j.cnki.1000-5579.2017.03.001

• 宗教社会学研究 •    下一篇

魏晋以来的“禅让革命”及其思想背景

楼劲   

  1. 中国社会科学院历史研究所, 北京 100732
  • 出版日期:2017-05-15 发布日期:2017-05-20
  • 作者简介:楼劲,中国社会科学院历史研究所研究员(北京,100732)。

The “Revolution within Abdication” in the Wei-Jin, Southern and Northern Dynasties and Its Intellectual Background

LOU Jin   

  • Online:2017-05-15 Published:2017-05-20

摘要:

魏晋南北朝盛行的禅代模式有其深刻的历史内涵和思想背景,其模式虽称革命而实质禅让,故可名为“禅让革命”。这一模式上承先秦、秦汉关于尧舜禅让和汤武革命传统的讨论,修正和组合了其所寓义涵,将之外化为一套高度程式化的禅代仪节,以此确认了公天下让贤原理在家天下时期的适用性,肯定了顺天而应人的革命大义为禅代辩护的价值,统一了其间关系和王朝易代的合法性理据。这就在圣王不再、纲常已立的时代,明确了权力和平过渡的可行途径,尽其所能地解决了对王朝体制发展来说至为关键的易代合法性的论证难题,应当视为古代政治文明的历史性进步。由于其具体论证过程仍面临着民意难定而天心莫测的困境,此期又不断倾向于以合乎古圣王治道的政教更张举措,来一体证成其易代上应天命而下合民意,因而使得整个模式的演化,呈现了从偏于禅让因循向较重革命改制过渡的态势。

关键词: 禅让, 革命, 易代模式, 王朝体系, 顺天应人

Abstract:

As for the abdication mode prevailing in the Wei-Jin, Southern and Northern Dynasties, there was profound historical and intellectual background. It can be called as the "revolution within abdication". Under the influence of the legends about the abdication of Yao and Shun and the revolution of Tang and Wu, and with the modification of their implications to form a series of highly routinized abdication ceremonies, this mode confirmed the adaptability of the principle of selecting talent and worthy men both in an age of "the world of the people" and that of "the world of a family", and affirmed the positive relationship between the revolution conforming to Heaven and the people on the one hand and the abdication on the other. In this way, it provided a feasible approach to transfer power in a peaceful way in a time when sagely kings would no longer exist while the constant virtues had been established and solved the difficult problem of how to prove the legitimacy of the change of dynasties, which was key to the development of the dynasty system. In this sense, it should be regarded as a historical progress in ancient political civilization. Since it was still difficult to affirm the will of the people and the mandate of Heaven, the authorities appealed to policies in accordance with the political teachings of ancient sagely kings to prove that the change of dynasties did conform to Heaven and the people. Consequently, the mode was transforming from abdication to revolution.

Key words: abdication, revolution, the mode of the change of dynasties, dynasty system, conforming to Heaven and the people