华东师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版) ›› 2023, Vol. 55 ›› Issue (6): 71-79.doi: 10.16382/j.cnki.1000-5579.2023.06.007

• 政治哲学研究 • 上一篇    下一篇

康德图式论的社会认识论审思——以阿多诺文化工业批判理论为视角

陆凯华   

  • 接受日期:2023-10-19 出版日期:2023-11-15 发布日期:2023-11-22
  • 作者简介:陆凯华,华东师范大学哲学系副教授(上海,200241),复旦大学当代国外马克思主义思潮研究中心研究员
  • 基金资助:
    国家社科基金重大项目“阿多诺文艺美学著作翻译、笺注与研究”(项目编号:21&ZD069)

On Kant’s Schema Theory in Social Epistemology:From the Perspective of Adorno’s Critical Theory of Culture Industry

Kai-hua LU   

  • Accepted:2023-10-19 Online:2023-11-15 Published:2023-11-22

摘要:

阿多诺基于马克思主义立场所开展的社会认识论批判,并非呈现为一套完备的学理体系,而是脱胎于他对现代工业社会理性形式的分析,尤其体现在他对文化工业的批判上。以大众文化为商品内容的文化工业生产系统,实现了以社会控制、消解认识自律性为目标的意识形态功能,实现了康德试图批判并加以限定的唯心主义认识论。在上述图景中,阿多诺的文化工业批判与康德的先验认识论的疑难(即图式论疑难),就此形成一种互文关系:一方面,文化工业的社会效应,引向了对康德知识论其社会实践意涵的再阐发;另一方面,阿多诺对康德图式论反讽式的借鉴,精准定位了文化工业实现社会控制的运作机理。就此,一种基于康德先验知识体系改造的社会认识论,可在文化工业批判开启的社会历史总体性中获得理论定向。

关键词: 图式, 阿多诺, 文化工业批判, 社会认识论

Abstract:

Adorno’s critique of social epistemology based on Marxism is not presented as a complete academic system. It is derived from his analysis of the rational form of modern industrial society in general and culture industry in particular. The cultural industrial production system with mass culture as its commodity content has realized the ideological function of social control and the elimination of cognitive autonomy. It has also realized the idealist epistemology that Kant tried to criticize and limit. In the above picture, Adorno’s critique of culture industry and Kant’s difficulty in transcendental epistemology, that is, the problem of his schema theory, form an intertextual relationship: On the one hand, the social effects of culture industry lead to re-elaborating the social practical implications of Kant’s theory of knowledge; on the other hand, Adorno’s ironic reference to Kant’s schema theory accurately positions the operating mechanism of culture industry to realize social control. In this regard, a social epistemology based on a revised version of Kant’s transcendental knowledge system can obtain a theoretical orientation in the socio-historical totality initiated by the critique of culture industry.

Key words: Schema, Adorno, critique of culture industry, social epistemology