华东师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版) ›› 2020, Vol. 52 ›› Issue (6): 62-75.doi: 10.16382/j.cnki.1000-5579.2020.06.008

• 语言学研究 • 上一篇    下一篇

“零句”论述质疑

史有为   

  1. 日本明海大学
  • 发布日期:2020-11-23
  • 作者简介:史有为,日本明海大学名誉教授。

Query on the Argument of a “Minor Sentence”

SHI You-wei   

  • Published:2020-11-23

摘要: "零句"是赵元任先生引入汉语的术语,是以汉语为本体自觉思考的一个尝试,并开创了摆脱印欧语眼光的研究道路。但是,"零句"论述存在多处疑点,如下列观点:(1)单句是由两个零句分别作为主语谓语的整句;(2)单句的主语—谓语是一问一答;(3)过分扩大的主语范围;(4)单句是最小的复杂句,复句的从句也是主语。为解决"零句"带来的问题,可以扩大对短语的理解,以替代"零句",并建立典型性原则。单句的典型性是:"主语/话题是指称,谓语/说明是陈述"。这也是汉语单句和复句区分的合理依据。

关键词: 零句, 指称/陈述, 主语/话题, 单句/复句, 典型性原则

Abstract: As an attempt to theoretically reflection on Chinese language itself, a “minor sentence” is a term introduced to Chinese by Mr. ZHAO Yuan-ren. This has opened up a research path independent of the Indo-European perspective. However, many details in the theory of a “minor sentence” are doubtful: (1) a single sentence is a full sentence with two minor sentences as the subject and the predicate; (2) the subject and the predicate of a single sentence are comprised of one question and one answer; (3) the subject scope is excessively enlarged; (4) a single sentence is the smallest complex sentence, and a clause of a complex sentence is also a subject. In order to solve these problems centering on a “minor sentence”, we can replace a “minor sentence” with a phrase with a broader meaning and establish the principle of typicality. The typicality of a single sentence is that “the subject/topic is a reference, while the predicate/description is a statement”. This is also a reasonable basis for the distinction between a single sentence and a complex sentence in Chinese.

Key words: minor sentence, reference, statement, subject/topic, single sentence, complex sentence, principle of typicality