华东师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版) ›› 2024, Vol. 56 ›› Issue (5): 103-115.doi: 10.16382/j.cnki.1000-5579.2024.05.010

• 法律前沿问题研究 • 上一篇    

创造性:数据与知识产权的联结点

王国柱, 袁帅   

  • 出版日期:2024-09-15 发布日期:2024-10-11
  • 作者简介:王国柱,吉林大学理论法学研究中心暨吉林大学法学院教授(长春,130012)|袁帅,吉林大学法学院博士研究生
  • 基金资助:
    国家社科基金项目“作品独创性的司法裁判逻辑研究”(项目编号:19BFX157)。

Creativity:The Nexus of Data and Intellectual Property

Guozhu Wang, Shuai Yuan   

  • Online:2024-09-15 Published:2024-10-11

摘要:

数据与知识产权理论联系的建立是数据获得知识产权法保护的前提,创造性能够成为数据与知识产权的联结点。知识产权权利体系的形成与扩张以创造性为基石,具备创造性是新的无形财产权益进入知识产权权利体系的基本条件。数据可以在形成过程与形式外观两方面体现创造性,前者体现在数据处理者对数据归集内容与加工处理规则的个性化选择和判断,后者则体现为数据经过加工后获得的有序性、信息揭示能力与预测指引功能。作为知识产权客体的数据的创造性可以从差异性、实质性加工与体现新价值三个方面界定。差异性指数据之间应当存在客观上可识别的、源于人的创造活动的差异;实质性加工指数据处理者应当实质性地塑造数据处理规则与实质性地参与数据加工处理过程;数据的新价值主要体现为信息揭示能力的提升、预测与指引功能的增强以及市场价值的提高。“经过实质性加工、具备差异性、产生新价值”的数据可以被认为是满足知识产权创造性要求的数据,能够获得知识产权法的保护。

关键词: 数据, 知识产权, 创造性, 实质性加工, 差异性

Abstract:

The establishment of the connection between data and intellectual property rights is a prerequisite for data to obtain the legal protection of the Intellectual Property Law. Creativity can become the link between data and intellectual property. The formation and expansion of the intellectual property system is based on creativity, and being creative is the basic condition for new intangible property rights to enter the intellectual property system. Creativity can be reflected in the formation process and the formal appearance of data. The former is embodied in the personal choice and judgment of the content of data collection and processing rules by the data processor, while the latter embodies the order of data after processing, the ability of information disclosure and the function of prediction guidance. As the object of intellectual property, the creativity of data can be defined from three aspects, i.e., distinctions, substantial processing and new values. Distinctions refer to the objective and identifiable distinctions of data that originate from human creative activities. Substantial processing refers to the data processor’s substantial shaping of data processing rules and substantial participation in the data processing process. New values of data are mainly reflected in the improvement of information disclosure capability, the enhancement of predictive and guiding function, and the increase in market value. Data that have undergone substantial processing, possessed distinctions, and generated new values can be considered as data that meet the creative requirements of intellectual property rights and can obtain the protection of the Intellectual Property Law.

Key words: data, intellectual property, creativity, substantial processing, distinctions