华东师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版) ›› 2024, Vol. 56 ›› Issue (2): 1-7.doi: 10.16382/j.cnki.1000-5579.2024.02.001

• 重启科技与人文对话 •    

人工智能意识“涌现论”的概念误区与未来视野

王峰   

  • 接受日期:2024-02-27 出版日期:2024-03-15 发布日期:2024-04-08
  • 作者简介:王峰,华东师范大学传播学院、中文系联聘教授(上海,200241)

The Misconception and the Future Perspective of the Emergence Theory of AI Consciousness

Feng Wang   

  • Accepted:2024-02-27 Online:2024-03-15 Published:2024-04-08

摘要:

人工智能是否具有意识?或未来是否可能具有意识?这是一个看起来有些不好回答的问题。涌现论似乎可以提供一个肯定性的回答。然而,考察涌现论的概念结构,却发现人工智能意识的涌现论更多的是由于概念的不断转用而导致的误解,而非真正的意识涌现。这一涌现论也非全无益处,它鼓舞社会观念对人工智能抱有更宽容的接纳态度,视之为有机性存在,而非单纯机器。涌现论不是一个本体性问题,而是一个包含未来揣测维度的实践问题。未来是否承认人工智能存在意识,只能由离未来最近的人们来决定。所以,人工智能的意识涌现论不仅是技术和实质对象的讨论,更是一个文化观念的讨论。

关键词: 人工智能, 意识涌现论, 概念分析

Abstract:

Does AI have consciousness? Or is it possible for AI to have consciousness in the future? This is a question that seems a bit difficult to answer. The emergence theory seems to provide a positive answer. However, an examination of the conceptual structure of the emergence theory shows that the emergence theory of AI consciousness is more of a misunderstanding caused by the continuous transformation of concepts and fails to confirm any true emergence of consciousness. The emergence theory is beneficial in the sense that it encourages our society to embrace AI more tolerantly, viewing it as an organic existence rather than a simple machine. What the emergence theory deals with is not an ontological problem, but a practical problem that includes the perspective of future speculation. Whether the future recognizes the existence of AI consciousness can only be determined by the people who are closest to the future. So, the emergence theory of AI consciousness is not only a matter of technology and substantive objects, but also a matter of cultural concepts.

Key words: AI, emergence theory of consciousness, conceptual analysis