华东师范大学(哲学社会科学版) ›› 2014, Vol. 46 ›› Issue (3): 140-144.

• 文学研究 • 上一篇    下一篇

《乾嘉诗坛点将录》作者考实
——为钱锺书先生祛疑

刘永翔   

  1. 华东师范大学古籍研究所,上海,200241
  • 出版日期:2014-05-15 发布日期:2014-09-29
  • 通讯作者: 刘永翔
  • 作者简介:刘永翔

On the Verification of the Author of the Records of the Elites in the Poetic Circles during the Reigns of Emperors Qianlong and Jiaqing: Removing Qiang Zhongshu’s Suspicion

Liu Yong-xiang   

  • Online:2014-05-15 Published:2014-09-29
  • Contact: Liu Yong-xiang
  • About author:Liu Yong-xiang

摘要: 《乾嘉诗坛点将录》一书,历来都认为是清诗人舒位(!云)所作,惟钱锺书先生据清贝青乔集中《为叶丈廷题〈诗坛点将录〉》一诗,断此“足证俗传舒铁云作之讹”。但此论未免千虑一失,据当时文人的雅习、《录》中诗人的不持异议、该《录》收藏者叶廷与题词作者的交往互动诸方面,可以看到此书绝非叶氏所作;据叶氏友人著述中的明确表达,更可见该录确系舒位之作。

关键词: 舒位, 贝青乔, 毕华珍, 刘履芬, 王汝玉

Abstract: It is always thought that the Records of the Elites in the Poetic Circles during the Reigns of Emperors Qianlong and Jiaqing was written by the poet Shu Wei (Tieyun) in the Qing Dynasty. It is only Qian Zhongshu who asserts that “it is sufficient to prove that Shu Tieyun is not the real author” according to the poem of the “Inscription of the Records for Senior Ye Ting” in the collection of Bei Qingqiao’s works in the Qing Dynasty. However, Qian’s opinion is suspicious. We can see that the book was absolutely not written by Ye Zhangting according to the following elements: the scholars’ elegant manners at that time, no objections from the poets mentioned in Records, and the interactions between Ye Ting, the collector of the book and the author of the “Inscription”. The explicit statements in the works of Ye’s then prove that the book was really written by Shu Wei.