华东师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版) ›› 2023, Vol. 55 ›› Issue (5): 81-94.doi: 10.16382/j.cnki.1000-5579.2023.05.009

• 法学研究 • 上一篇    下一篇

论我国轻罪案件出罪机制的逻辑与路径

杜文俊   

  • 出版日期:2023-09-15 发布日期:2023-09-28
  • 作者简介:杜文俊,上海社会科学院研究员(上海,200235)
  • 基金资助:
    国家社科基金一般项目“行政犯入罪机制与出罪路径的实证研究”(项目编号:19BFX067)

On the Mechanism of Decriminalization of Misdemeanor Cases:Practice,Logic and Path

Wen-jun DU   

  • Online:2023-09-15 Published:2023-09-28

摘要:

轻罪化立法从根本上推动了我国刑事犯罪结构的重大变化,结合轻罪特殊属性展开出罪机制建构是适应犯罪治理现代化的核心问题。以应然价值为导向寻求轻罪出罪的立法建构固然重要,但尊重现实从既有规范制度展开探索则更为关键。因此,必须正视当前轻罪化立法格局已然形成,司法重刑主义倾向并未得到有效转变的轻罪刑事治理客观现实,理性认识到推进轻罪出罪机制建构的政策逻辑、实践逻辑以及内在理论逻辑。基于此,在轻罪治理理念上需以消极主义司法消解积极主义立法的客观隐患,实现以出罪思维优位于入罪思维的现实转变;在实体规范上应激活既有规范出罪功能,以罪量要素的目的性解释为关键,强化“但书”及免予刑事处罚等规则在轻罪治理中出罪出刑作用的发挥;在程序规范上,应以既有制度改革为契机,深度挖掘酌定不起诉等制度内在独立的出罪价值。

关键词: 轻罪, 出罪机制, 谦抑主义, 消极刑法观, 程序出罪

Abstract:

Misdemeanor legislation fundamentally promotes major changes in the criminal structure, and constructing a mechanism of decriminalization for the special attributes of misdemeanors is the core issue to adapting to the modernization of crime governance. It is important to seek legislative solutions to solve problems, but it is even more critical to respect reality and explore existing normative systems. Since the current misdemeanor legislation has been formed, it is necessary to rationally realize that the promotion of the establishment of the mechanism of decriminalization of misdemeanors is supported by firm policy logic, sufficient practical logic, and internal theoretical logic. Therefore, in terms of governance concepts, it is necessary to complete the transformation from positive justice to negative justice, from guilt thinking to not-guilt thinking; in terms of substantive norms, we shall activate the existing normative crime function, and strengthen the role of rules such as saving clause and conviction but Exemption from Punishment causes in the governance of misdemeanors; in terms of procedural settings, we shall take the reform of the existing system as an opportunity to deeply explore the value of independent decriminalization such as discretionary non-prosecution.

Key words: misdemeanor, the mechanism of decriminalization, modesty, the negative concept of criminal law, procedural decriminalization