华东师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版) ›› 2026, Vol. 58 ›› Issue (1): 124-135.doi: 10.16382/j.cnki.1000-5579.2026.01.012

• 韦伯政治社会学研究 • 上一篇    

韦伯的民族主义与自由主义:方法论下的政治观

王赟   

  • 接受日期:2025-12-31 出版日期:2026-01-15 发布日期:2026-02-02
  • 作者简介:王赟,苏州大学社会学院副研究员,斯特拉斯堡大学欧洲动态研究中心客座研究员,苏州大学苏南治理现代化研究基地研究员(苏州, 215123)

Weber’s Nationalism and Liberalism: Political Views from a Methodological Perspective

Yun Wang   

  • Accepted:2025-12-31 Online:2026-01-15 Published:2026-02-02

摘要:

韦伯敏感于他所处的巨变时代,并认为现代性的主要文化中都表现出理智化的特征,且理智化并非救世良药。具体到韦伯的现实关怀,他一直关注德国这一文化意义上的“自我”在理知化的世界中应具有何种地位。从韦伯学说的思维图示出发,即从19世纪末德国自身的社会科学传统对韦伯的影响出发,可以分析方法论视角下韦伯思想中民族主义倾向和自由主义倾向的纠缠。研究认为,韦伯学说并非建立在古典的民族主义与自由主义概念对应上,韦伯的思想既是独创的整体,又必然受到当时文化思潮和科学传统的影响,与其从当今流行的概念出发断定韦伯的立场,不如以这种观念纠缠为线索,在更为综合的意义上理解韦伯学说及其意义。

关键词: 韦伯的民族主义, 韦伯的自由主义, 方法论, 定规

Abstract:

Weber was sensitive to the era of radical changes in which he lived and believed that there was rationalization in major cultures. Meanwhile, rationalization is not a cure for the world. Specifically, regarding Weber’s concern for reality, he has always paid attention to the status of Germany, the “self” in the cultural sense in the intellectualized world. This paper starts from the image used in Weber’s theory, that is, the influence of Germany’s own social science tradition at the end of the 19th century on Weber, and analyzes the entanglement of nationalism and liberalism in Weber from a methodological perspective. Weber’s theory is not based on the concepts corresponding to classical nationalism and liberalism. His theory is an original entity, while it is also influenced by the cultural thought and scientific tradition at that time. Rather than judging Weber’s position from contemporary popular concepts, it is more fruitful to take conceptual entanglement as a clue for understanding his theoretical framework and its significance from a more comprehensive perspective.

Key words: Weber’s nationalism, Weber’s liberalism, methodology, established practice