华东师范大学(哲学社会科学版) ›› 2018, Vol. 50 ›› Issue (1): 1-8.doi: 10.16382/j.cnki.1000-5579.2018.01.001

• 专题讨论:再写中国伦理学 •    下一篇

“伦理”与“道德”之辨——关于“再写中国伦理学”的一点思考

朱贻庭   

  1. 华东师范大学哲学系 上海 200241
  • 出版日期:2018-01-15 发布日期:2018-01-26
  • 作者简介:朱贻庭,华东师范大学哲学系教授(上海,200241)。

The Distinction between “Ethics” and “Morality”: On “Rewriting Chinese Ethics”

ZHU Yi-ting   

  • Online:2018-01-15 Published:2018-01-26

摘要: 长期以来,伦理学界将"伦理"与"道德"视为"相近相通",并"互相替用"。然史实并非如此。在古希腊"伦理"与"道德"就有区别,黑格尔更将两者"严格分开";在中国古代,早有"伦理"("人伦")与"道德"这两个用词。"伦理"是既亲亲又尊尊的客观人际"关系","道德"是由"伦理"关系所规定的角色个体的义务,并通过修养内化为德性。"伦理"正则道德兴,"伦理"乱则道德衰,所谓"道德失范",原因正在于"伦理失序"。辨析"伦理"与"道德"的区别与联系,具有重要的理论价值和实践意义:既是总结古典中国伦理学的前提和切入点,并为论述"天人合一"、"心性之辨"、"义利之辨"、"和同之辨"等道德哲学提供逻辑的和经验的根据;通过批判的继承,又能为当代中国伦理学找准研究的对象,因而也是再写中国伦理学的一个不可或缺的理论前提,从而可为道德建设提供学理性的理论依据。"‘伦理’‘道德’之辨"是再写中国伦理学的一个重要的"理论范式"。

关键词: 伦理与道德, 伦理实体, 伦理本位, 伦理精神

Abstract: Ethics and "morality" have been regarded as similar concepts that can replace each other in the ethic circle for a long time. However, this was not true in history. They were different in ancient Greece and Hegel even strictly made a distinction between them. The Chinese terms respectively for ethics and morality, that is, lunli(or renlun) and daode, did appear in ancient China. Ethics means objective human relationships, in which people love the beloved and respect the senior, while morality means the duties of an individual in accordance to his or her ethical roles, which shall be internalized as virtues through cultivation. Morality thrives with right ethics and declines when ethics is in disorder. That is to say, the chaos of ethics leads to moral disorder. It is of great theoretical and practical significance to examine the difference and connection between ethics and morality. It is the premise as well as the starting point of generalizing the ethics in ancient China. Meanwhile, it provides logic and experiential foundation for discussing moral issues such as the "unity of Heaven and human", the "distinction between the mind-heart(xin) and nature(xing)", the "distinction between righteousness(yi) and profit(li)" and the "distinction between harmony(he) and sameness(tong)". By inheriting the tradition in a critical way, we can find out appropriate subject for today's Chinese ethics and hence provide an indispensable theoretical premise for rewriting Chinese ethics as well as theoretical foundation for moral construction. The distinction between ethics and morality can serve as an important "theoretical paradigm" for rewriting Chinese ethics.

Key words: ethics and morality, ethic entity, ethics as the essence, ethic spirit