华东师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版) ›› 2021, Vol. 53 ›› Issue (3): 43-58.doi: 10.16382/j.cnki.1000-5579.2021.03.004

• 哲学与文化 • 上一篇    下一篇

“普遍历史”构思的文明论困局

陈赟   

  • 出版日期:2021-05-15 发布日期:2021-05-24
  • 作者简介:陈赟,华东师范大学中国现代思想文化研究所暨哲学系教授(上海,200241)
  • 基金资助:
    国家社科基金重点项目“礼运学的综合研究”(18AZX009)、江苏省公民道德与社会风尚协同中心和智库建设项目(2014)、上海市教育委员会科研创新计划(201701070005E00053)、华东师范大学“中国古典思想研究”跨学科创新团队(2018ECNU-QKT010)

The Predicament of Universal History from the Perspective of Civilization

Yun CHEN   

  • Online:2021-05-15 Published:2021-05-24

摘要:

以思辨形态构建“普遍历史”的努力,作为一种思想规划与思想实验,它根基于基督教救赎史与末世论的思想架构,以超越的普遍性应对历史生存中的无常体验。然而它不可避免地导致以下问题:历史目的与历史主体的断裂,使得历史本身脱离了具体个人的生存;历史中的生存本来是参与性的,但在普遍历史构思中具体个人反而成为旁观者;由于历史体验中的无常感受被等同于意义虚无体验,历史意义于是被构思为来自超越性的历史目的之植入,因而历史中的生存被贬抑为一种克服历史本身而朝向超越性终点的驿站。由此隐藏在近代西方普遍历史构思中的恰恰是一种逃离历史的非历史性意识,这意味着作为一种思想实验的普遍历史规划的内在危机。

关键词: 普遍历史, 黑格尔, 意义, 精神

Abstract:

The effort to construct “universal history” in a metaphysical way, as a kind of ideological planning and thought experiment, is based on the ideological framework of Christian redemption history and eschatology. It responds to the impermanence experience in historical existence with transcendental universality. However, it inevitably leads to the following problems. First, the rupture of historical purpose and historical subject makes history itself divorced from the survival of specific individuals. Second, though the existence in history shall be involved, specific individuals become bystanders in the conception of universal history. Third, when the feeling of impermanence in historical experience is equal to the experience of meaninglessness, the historical meaning is conceived as the implantation of transcendental historical purpose so that the existence in history is degraded as a kind of station that overcomes history itself and directs towards the transcendental end. What is hidden in the conception of modern Western universal history is precisely a non-historical consciousness of escaping from history, which indicates the inherent crisis of the planning of universal history as a thought experiment.

Key words: universal history, Hegel, meaning, spirit