华东师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版) ›› 2022, Vol. 54 ›› Issue (4): 88-97.doi: 10.16382/j.cnki.1000-5579.2022.04.009

• 重启科技与人文对话 • 上一篇    下一篇

科学技术与人文学术的辩证关系——兼论远读与细读的对立与互补

王宁   

  • 接受日期:2022-06-14 出版日期:2022-07-15 发布日期:2022-07-26
  • 作者简介:王宁,上海交通大学人文学院文科资深教授,欧洲科学院外籍院士(上海,200240)

The Dialectical Relations between Science and Technology and Humanities:On the Opposition and Complementarity between Distant Reading and Close Reading

Ning WANG   

  • Accepted:2022-06-14 Online:2022-07-15 Published:2022-07-26

摘要:

在不少人看来,科技与人文天然就是对立的,因而他们便对数字人文抱有偏见。毫无疑问,作为一种新的研究范式,数字人文带给我们的研究诸多便利,使我们摆脱了繁琐的资料追踪和检索,而把更多的时间和精力用于对研究对象的深入思考和理论阐释。用于世界文学研究,大数据的方法可以在短时间内使我们得出世界文学发展的概貌,这已被美国学者莫瑞提提出的远读方法所证明。但是任何事物都有其两面性:远读方法的运用虽然有自己的长项,但在具体深入研究世界文学经典作家及其作品时,还必须辅之以细读方法,因此这两种方法可以形成一种互补关系。总之,数字人文并没有截然排斥人文,特别是那些文化和美学含量很高的优秀文学作品和人文学术著作,它们都是优秀的作家和学者倾心创作出来的,任何才华稍逊于他们的人都无法替代他们。翻译也是如此,即使机器和人工智能翻译也不能取代高级的文学和人文学术翻译。理想的文学研究应该是将远读与细读方法有机地结合在一起,形成一种互补关系,因为科技与人文本身就有着某种互补的关系。

关键词: 数字人文, 远读, 细读, 人文学术, 世界文学研究

Abstract:

In many people’s view, science and technology and humanities are naturally in a state of opposition, so they have a prejudice against digital humanities. There is no doubt that digital humanities, as a new research paradigm, will bring us a lot of research convenience, with which we get rid of the cumbersome data tracking and retrieval so as to save more time and energy for in-depth thinking and theoretical interpretation of the research object. For the study of world literature, the big data method can give us a general picture of the historical development of world literature in a short time, which has been proved by the distant reading method proposed by American Italian scholar Franco Moretti. Nevertheless, everything has its two sides: the application of “distant reading” method has its own strengths, but in-depth study of world literature classics and their authors should be supplemented by the close reading method. Therefore, the two methods can form a complementary relationship. In short, digital humanities do not definitely exclude humanities, especially those irreplaceable excellent literary works and humanities works with high cultural and aesthetic content created by excellent writers or scholars. Similarly, machine and AI translation cannot replace advanced literary and humanities translation. The ideal literary research should combine the methods of distant reading and close reading so as to form a complementary relationship. Effectively, there is complementarity between science and technology and humanities.

Key words: digital humanities, distant reading, close reading, humanities, world literature studies