华东师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版) ›› 2022, Vol. 54 ›› Issue (1): 60-68.doi: 10.16382/j.cnki.1000-5579.2022.01.006

• 哲学研究 • 上一篇    下一篇

康德的“曲木直木”之辩

鲍永玲   

  • 接受日期:2021-12-09 出版日期:2022-01-15 发布日期:2022-01-22
  • 作者简介:鲍永玲,上海社会科学院哲学研究所研究员(上海,200235)

Kant’s Discussion on “Crooked Timber” and “Straight Wood”

Yong-ling BAO   

  • Accepted:2021-12-09 Online:2022-01-15 Published:2022-01-22

摘要:

康德在《世界公民观点之下的普遍历史观念》里,提出了著名的“曲木”难题,并认为这里面体现出的悖论既是最困难的问题,也是最后才能被人类解决的问题。与此相应,康德运用“曲木”和“森林里的直木”这一对略显矛盾的核心隐喻,系统地阐释了个体自由与社会法律秩序之复杂互动的关系。“曲木”隐喻也可说是柏拉图“洞穴隐喻”对人类感性缺陷描述的变种。它暗示人首先是自然秩序中的存在,这是一种“实然”的经验性问题,也就是人实际上是什么。而“直木”则体现了“应然”的价值追求,即人应当成为什么。它体现了个体在社会共同体里可能发展成为独立人格性的禀赋,凸显了人的个性和独立意识、人的尊严和价值。“曲木?直木”隐喻及其从属隐喻,是通向康德独特人类学观念的路径之一,也与康德对“自然”观念的反思和重构有着重要的关联。

关键词: 曲木, 直木, 人性, 权利, 自然

Abstract:

In “The Universal Concept of History from the Perspective of World Citizens”, Kant puts forward the famous “crooked timber” puzzle, believing that the paradox reflected in it is the most difficult problem and the final problem that can be solved by mankind. Accordingly, Kant systematically interprets the complex interactive relationship between individual freedom and social legal order by using the core metaphors of “crooked timber” and “straight wood in the forest”, which seem to be contradictory. The metaphor of “crooked timber” can also be regarded as a variation of Plato’s “cave metaphor” describing human perceptual defects. It implies that man, above all, is an existence in the order of nature, which is an empirical issue concerning “what it is in reality”, that is, “what human beings are in practice”, whereas “straight wood” demonstrates a value pursuit of “what it should be”, that is “what human beings should be like”. It shows that individuals’ potential to develop independent personality in social community and hence highlights human beings’ individuality, awareness of being independent, human dignity and value. The metaphors of “crooked timber” and “straight wood” together with other subordinate metaphors help to approach Kant’s unique anthropological concept and play an important role in Kant’s reflection and reconstruction of the concept of “nature”.

Key words: crooked timber, straight wood, human nature, right, nature